City · NY

Shelter Island Heights CDP

Typical home value

$2,025,914[1]

Population-weighted median across this city's ZIP codes (Zillow ZHVI). See methodology.

At a glance

Population
404[2]
ZIP codes
1[4]
Median rent
—[3]
Median home value
$2,025,914[1]

Price history

Population-weighted median Zillow Home Value Index across this city's ZIP codes, monthly.[1]

Highest-value ZIPs

The five ZIP codes in Shelter Island Heights CDP with the highest typical home value.

11965

HousingHandbook provides informational data and educational content about US residential real estate. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, real estate, tax, or legal advice, or a recommendation to buy, sell, finance, or invest in any property or security. Data may contain errors or be out of date; always verify any information independently and consult licensed professionals before making real estate, financial, or legal decisions.

© 2026 HousingHandbook.